White fillings are made of composite resin, a tooth-coloured material that is bonded to the tooth. Amalgam fillings are the traditional silver-grey fillings, made of a metal alloy that is packed into a shaped cavity. Both repair decay well. The main differences are appearance, how much healthy tooth needs removing, and where each is now used. Sound amalgam fillings do not need replacing simply because they are amalgam.
Many adults have a mix of both. Here is how they compare, and how to decide what to do about old fillings.
How each type works
Amalgam
Amalgam is an alloy of silver, tin, copper and mercury. It is placed soft, packed into the cavity and hardens over the following hours. Because it does not stick to the tooth, the cavity has to be shaped to hold it in place mechanically, which often means removing some healthy tooth structure. Amalgam is very hard-wearing and has been used for well over a century.
Composite (white fillings)
Composite is a resin containing fine glass or ceramic particles. It is placed in layers, each hardened with a curing light, then shaped and polished. Because it bonds to the tooth, the dentist only needs to remove the decay itself, leaving more natural tooth behind. It can be colour-matched to the surrounding teeth. At our practice, we place tooth-coloured composite fillings; details are on our fillings page.
Side by side
| Composite (white) | Amalgam (silver) | |
|---|---|---|
| Appearance | Matched to the tooth | Silver-grey, darkens over time |
| How it stays in | Bonded to the tooth | Held by the shape of the cavity |
| Tooth removed | Usually less | Usually more |
| Placement | Needs the tooth kept dry; takes a little longer | More tolerant of moisture |
| Durability | Many last 7–10 years or longer | Often 10–15 years or longer |
| Current use | The standard filling in most practices | Being phased down internationally |
Durability depends heavily on the size of the filling, where it is in the mouth, grinding and cleaning, so these ranges are a guide rather than a promise.
Is amalgam safe?
Amalgam contains mercury, which understandably worries people. Major dental and health bodies, including the Australian Dental Association, regard amalgam fillings as safe for most people. The amount of mercury vapour released from set amalgam is very small.
Use of amalgam is being reduced worldwide under the Minamata Convention on Mercury, largely for environmental reasons. It is generally avoided in children, and during pregnancy and breastfeeding, where a suitable alternative exists.
Should I replace my old amalgam fillings?
Not just because they are amalgam. Removing a sound filling takes away more tooth each time and briefly increases mercury vapour exposure. Replacement makes sense when a filling is:
- Cracked, chipped or worn down
- Leaking, with decay starting around its edge
- Associated with a crack in the tooth
- Very large, leaving thin walls at risk of splitting, in which case a crown may protect the tooth better
- On a front or visible tooth where you would like a better colour match
We check the edges of existing fillings at each check-up and on bitewing X-rays, and will tell you if one needs attention.
Does getting a filling hurt?
Most fillings are done under local anaesthetic, with numbing gel applied before the injection. You may feel pressure and vibration but should not feel pain. If you are anxious, tell us when you book and we will allow extra time.
Some sensitivity to cold for a few days afterwards is common, particularly after a deep filling. Pain that lingers long after the cold has gone, or that keeps you awake, is not normal and should be checked. Our article on sensitive teeth covers other causes of sensitivity.
When a filling is not enough
A filling relies on enough healthy tooth around it for support. When most of a tooth’s structure has gone, or a cusp has broken off, a large filling can leave thin walls that crack under chewing. A crown, which covers and protects the whole tooth, is then usually the more durable option. Our article on filling or crown explains how that decision is made.
Cost
Tooth-coloured fillings at our practice are $209 to $450. The cost depends on how many surfaces of the tooth are involved and how deep the decay goes. We confirm it after an examination and before treatment starts.
You may also be interested in restorative dentistry.
Common questions
Can a white filling go on a back tooth?
Yes. Modern composites are strong enough for most back teeth. Very large restorations on heavily loaded molars may be better served by a crown.
Do white fillings stain?
They can pick up some surface stain from coffee, tea, red wine or smoking over the years. Polishing at a check-up removes most of it.
My filling fell out. What should I do?
Keep the area clean, avoid chewing on that side and book in. See lost filling or crown for what to do in the meantime.
Will my health fund cover a filling?
Fillings usually fall under general dental in extras cover, subject to your limits. HICAPS lets you claim at the appointment.
Booking an appointment in Canberra City
Civic Gentle Dental Care is a dentist in Canberra City at Suite 8, Level 3/161 London Circuit, a short walk from the Canberra Centre. To arrange an appointment, call (02) 6247 0224 or send us a message through our contact page.
This article is general information only and is not a substitute for individual dental advice. Whether a treatment is suitable for you, and what it will involve, can only be determined after an examination by a dentist. Any prices mentioned are estimates drawn from our current price guide and are not a quote.
